Hackers turned 700 freezers into ovens.

Something breaks, and Wall Street buys the companies that sell protection.

In partnership with

Happy Sunday.

On the night of October 11, somebody logged into the refrigeration controls at about 700 French grocery stores and told the freezers to defrost. By morning the cases were at 122 degrees. At least 15 stores had fires. In one small town in eastern France, just two supermarkets threw out more than a quarter million dollars of food.

Nobody robs a freezer. There's nothing in it to steal, which is why nobody had bothered to lock these. The way around their login had been published in 2023.

Wall Street has a habit for moments like this. Something breaks, and it buys the companies that sell protection. CrowdStrike rose as much as 12 percent in a day on AI warnings in September. Palo Alto Networks rose 7 percent the day a flaw turned up in the code under 70 percent of the world's websites. Both got bought twice this Friday, in the morning while Microsoft's email was down and again after the close, when the FAA had grounded every departure in America. As far as anyone can tell, neither outage was a hack.

CrowdStrike has doubled this year. The main cybersecurity ETF is up more than 35 percent, against about 12 for the Nasdaq 100. And in a week when Jensen Huang resigned from Nvidia and the planes stopped, the S&P 500 rose 2.5 percent.

So the market's view is settled. A cyber scare is good business for the vendors and a rounding error for everybody else.

I think that's wrong on both counts. Nothing that failed this fall was a surprise. Each failure ran through a known problem, written down in public, that nobody had gotten around to fixing. If you run a company, there's a list like that with your name on it.

It was written down

Stay with the freezers for a minute.

The controllers come from a Danish company called Danfoss, and most of the ones that got hit were models it had stopped supporting. After the 2023 login bypass, the U.S. cyber agency flagged another flaw in May 2025. IPinfo, a firm that scans the internet, counted about 2,500 of these dashboards sitting on the open web in every scan from March to October. France blames Iran's Revolutionary Guard for what happened next, and nobody has claimed it took any special talent.

The rest of the fall reads the same way. Researchers using AI found two critical flaws in PHP, the language most websites run on, in August. The fix shipped October 21, and two days later Censys still counted 33 million exposed servers out of 41 million. The $6.3 billion that left Binance in 20 minutes went, the FBI says, to the same North Korean crew it named for the Bybit heist in February 2025. And officials say Friday's FAA outage wasn't an attack. The early explanation is security patches overloading routers that CBS reports were built between 2001 and 2006, in a system a 2024 government audit had already rated three quarters unsustainable or close to it.

None of this took a genius, because none of it was hidden.

A list used to be a safe place

What protected a known flaw was the shortage of people who could use it.

When a researcher finds a security hole, the custom is to publish it, often with proof-of-concept code (a short program showing the flaw is real). Len Noe, a security architect at BeyondTrust, told the Wall Street Journal why that was safe for so long. The system had a filter built in, and the filter was skill. Getting from a blog post to a working attack took someone who understood the code, and there were never many of those people.

Noe's point was that AI took the filter out. CrowdStrike published the new math on November 5. Of the flaws it watched attackers use between January and July, 91 percent were hit within 48 hours of the proof-of-concept going public. The fastest was 35 minutes. With PHP, Cloudflare counted tens of thousands of attack attempts in the first 45.

The warning and the weapon are the same document.

That changes who gets hit. When a break-in took talent, the talent went where the money was, and so did the security budget. Banks got good at this and grocers never had to. When a break-in costs almost nothing, a target with nothing to steal is worth hitting for the damage alone. There are a lot more freezers than banks.

The index never flinches

A scare lasts a day, and the bill lands somewhere the index can't see.

Binance covered the $6.3 billion out of its own treasury and reopened withdrawals within days. The French grocers threw the food out. Reuters reports their cyber insurance probably won't cover it, because those policies rarely pay for physical losses, and the chains are headed for a legal fight over who does.

The cost is real. It arrives as a tax, a little every quarter, while the market watches for a crash. Gartner puts security spending at $247.5 billion this year, up 13.6 percent, on its way to $373 billion by 2030. That money comes out of somebody's margin.

And the forecasts leave out a second cost. Hurrying fixes into old systems breaks them. On Friday, Reuters listed nine of the biggest tech outages since 2020. Not one is described as an attack, and two came from security tools themselves: a CrowdStrike update that crashed Windows machines around the world in July 2024, and a Cloudflare security file that took down a network carrying a fifth of web traffic last November. If the FAA's early explanation holds, that's three in 28 months.

So everybody who owns old equipment now gets the same bad choice. Patch slowly and you're the freezer. Patch quickly and you're the FAA.

Today’s Sponsor

Anthropic IPO: how do traders get 2x the move?

Anthropic is going public, and GraniteShares is launching two 2x ETFs on it.

AIL → bullish, seeks 2x Anthropic’s daily move
ANS → bearish, seeks 2x the opposite

Anthropic +1% → AIL seeks +2%
Anthropic −1% → ANS seeks +2%

Built for traders who want to act on a short-term view of Anthropic, up or down, in one ticker, no margin needed.

Coming soon to your trading apps.

The fund does not invest in the underlying stock. Investment in these funds is not an investment in the underlying stock. Investment in these ETFs involve significant risk and are a short-term trading vehicle. Please go through the Prospectus and risk information before investing. Funds are distributed by ALPS Distributors, Inc. For important risk disclosures, learn more at https://graniteshares.com/

The locksmith at 150 times earnings

Security revenue is somebody else's cost, and software is the cheap part of the bill.

CrowdStrike trades around 150 times estimated 2027 earnings and Palo Alto at 76. CrowdStrike sizes its own market at $550 billion by 2034.

I believe the demand. CrowdStrike says one Fortune 100 client used its new tool to find nearly 45 million vulnerabilities within hours. But look at what that product does. It writes the list, faster than anyone ever has. Somebody still has to work down 45 million items on live systems without breaking them. That work is labor and downtime, and often it means buying new hardware to replace gear the vendor gave up on years ago. None of it trades as a growth stock.

A $550 billion market for the locksmith is a $550 billion bill for everybody else. The AI trade counts what cheap intelligence saves. It doesn't yet count what it costs to keep cheap intelligence out.

Nvidia was on a list too

Nvidia is the one thing the market did sell, and it read only the top line of the list.

Nvidia fell 12.75 percent on the week, its sixth straight weekly loss, after Huang resigned on Thursday. AMD and Broadcom each gained about 18 percent. Wall Street read it as one man's problem, kept its money in AI chips and changed seats.

This was written down too. On May 13 a short seller called Culper Research published 40 pages on Megaspeed, a Singapore company that buys Nvidia chips. It alleged the chips were reaching China and called Huang's relationship with a Megaspeed executive "uncomfortably close." (Culper was short the stock, so discount accordingly.) On October 29 the New York Times reported that U.S. intelligence suspected that executive of spying for China.

The part that matters for the AI trade is the chips. American AI is valued as if China can't get the best ones. The Information reports that at least $7.5 billion of Nvidia chips moved through Megaspeed, and CBS says investigators believe 240,000 restricted chips were reached through shell companies. Megaspeed denies wrongdoing and nobody has been charged. Huang admitted an affair, not handing anything over, and Beijing calls the spy claim a smear.

If even part of that holds up, nobody hacked anything here either. Rules written in Washington to guard the most valuable hardware on earth were walked around through a customer relationship.

The best argument against me

AI defends too, and the defenders have more money. The largest companies can afford the tax, which is part of why all eleven S&P sectors rose this week.

My claim is narrower. Defense wins where somebody can afford to fix fast and safely, and a lot of the physical economy can't. The November freezer wave reached three sites run by France's national blood service. Freezers, blood banks and 20-year-old routers don't trade on the Nasdaq, but everything that does sits on top of them.

Tells I'm watching

Usual reminder, I'm not a financial advisor and none of this is advice.

How confident should you be? In the models, plenty. In what they're being plugged into, less than the S&P was this week.

I'm watching for the first large company that trims its margin outlook and names security or system replacement as the reason. That's when the tax shows up where the index can see it.

I'm watching the patch gap. If Censys is still counting exposed PHP servers in the millions at New Year's, the speed of repair is the real ceiling on how safe any of this gets.

And I'm watching the Megaspeed count. Nvidia reports earnings this coming week, and Anthropic is due to price its IPO on Wednesday at up to $1.4 trillion. If investigators confirm chips moved at the scale being reported, both are priced off a lead over China that is smaller than it looked in September.

One last number from France. Three days after the attack, IPinfo scanned again, and three quarters of the French dashboards were gone from the internet. The fix had been on the list the whole time. You unplug the thing from the web. It took 15 fires to get somebody to drive out and do it.

Whatever you run has a list like that. As of this fall you're not the only one reading it, and the other reader needs about 35 minutes.

Stay curious 😎

John

Today’s Sponsor

The 10 Best Stocks for Fall 2026

MarketBeat analysts just updated their 10 Best Stocks to Own for Fall 2026 report. The list includes AI growth names, a high-yield dividend payer, a steady portfolio diversifier and companies positioned for continued growth into year-end. Get all 10 stocks and the research behind them for free now.